Choosing Dental Indemnity: Contractual vs. Discretionary Policies – Making an Informed Decision for Aspiring Dental Professionals


As you embark on your journey in the field of dentistry, it is in your best interest to be aware of the various dental indemnity options available to you. While membership organisations that offer cheap discretionary policies might seem appealing at first, it is essential to exercise caution and consider the potential risks involved. In this blog post, we will explore the differences between discretionary policies and contractual dental indemnity and discuss why the latter is often a safer and more reliable choice.


Understanding Discretionary Policies:

Membership organisations that offer discretionary policies operate under a unique model. Instead of providing legally binding contracts that guarantee indemnity, they rely on discretionary powers to determine whether a member’s claim should be paid out. In other words, they have the discretion to accept or deny claims based on their own internal policies and guidelines. While this flexibility may sound attractive, it can lead to uncertainty and potential pitfalls for dental professionals.


The Risks of Discretionary Policies:

Lack of Legal Certainty: Since discretionary policies are not contractual, dental professionals have limited legal recourse if their claims are denied. Discretionary organisations can change their policies or even decline to pay claims altogether, leaving dentists in a vulnerable position.


Inconsistent Claim Outcomes: The discretionary nature of these organisations means that the outcome of a claim can vary from case to case. Claims may be declined even if they seem reasonable, which can be frustrating and financially burdensome for dental professionals.


Financial Uncertainty: With discretionary policies, the amount of indemnity received is uncertain. Dentists may not be able to accurately predict the level of coverage they will receive, making it challenging to plan for potential liabilities.


The Benefits of Contractual Dental Indemnity:

Contractual dental indemnity, on the other hand, offers clear and binding agreements between the dental professional and the indemnity provider. This means that if the agreed-upon conditions are met, the provider is obligated to honour the claims made by the dentist.


Legal Protection: Contractual indemnity provides a solid legal framework that protects both parties involved. Dental professionals have the security of knowing that their claims will be honoured if they adhere to the terms of the contract.


Predictable Coverage: With contractual dental indemnity, professionals can accurately assess the level of coverage they will receive. This allows for better financial planning and peace of mind, knowing that potential liabilities are adequately addressed.


Transparent Claims Process: Contractual indemnity organisations have clear guidelines and procedures for submitting claims. This transparency reduces the risk of claims being denied arbitrarily and ensures a fair and consistent approach to claim resolution.


While membership organisations offering discretionary policies may seem attractive on the surface, the potential risks and uncertainties associated with them make contractual dental indemnity a more reliable choice for dental professionals. By opting for a contractual indemnity provider, you can ensure legal protection, predictable coverage, and a transparent claims process, giving you the peace of mind to focus on providing excellent dental care without unnecessary financial risks.


Remember, your choice of dental indemnity can have significant implications for your professional career and financial well-being. Therefore, it is essential to conduct thorough research, seek professional advice, and make an informed decision that aligns with your needs and safeguards your future as a dental professional.

All Med Pro only provides Contract Certain policies to provide peace of mind to dental and health professionals.


Contact Us Today

If you have a query, give us a call at 0203 757 6950 or drop us an email via [email protected]

Alternatively, book a FREE consultation call with an expert member of our team: All Med Pro (


For peace of mind that you and your business reputation are protected, contact All Med Pro for all your insurance needs.

Share this post: